Chapter 12 • Simulation 01 Geiger-Marsden Benchmark

Rutherford Scattering & The Nuclear Atom Bench

Reconstruct Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden's landmark 1911 gold foil experiment, trace exact hyperbolic Coulomb trajectories at varying impact parameters ($b$), calculate the nuclear distance of closest approach ($r_0 \approx 41.4\text{ fm}$), and discover how Rutherford's nuclear model disproved Thomson's plum-pudding atom.

Geiger-Marsden Experiment: 5.5 MeV Alpha Beam on Gold Foil (Z = 79) → Large-Angle Scattering at θ = 45°
Alpha Energy $K$ 5.50 MeV Velocity: 1.63 × 10⁷ m/s (5.4% c)
Impact Parameter $b$ 10.0 fm $b = \frac{Z e^2 \cot(\theta/2)}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 K}$
Distance of Closest Approach 41.4 fm Nuclear Limit: $R_{\text{nucl}} < 41.4\text{ fm}$
Count Rate $N(\theta)/N(90^\circ)$ 1 in 8,200 Rutherford Law: $N \propto \frac{1}{\sin^4(\theta/2)}$
📈

Rutherford Differential Scattering Distribution $N(\theta)$

Inverse 4th Power Law
Foundational Principles

Atomic Structure & The Nuclear Discovery

A comprehensive pedagogical analysis of J.J. Thomson's plum-pudding failure, the Geiger-Marsden scattering experiments, Coulomb hyperbolic orbits, and the distance of closest approach defining nuclear dimensions.

🍮

1. J.J. Thomson's Plum-Pudding Model (1898)

Thomson visualized the atom as a spherical cloud of positive charge of radius $R \approx 10^{-10}\text{ m}$, in which tiny negatively charged electrons were embedded like plums in a pudding:

$$\begin{aligned} E_{\max} &= \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{Z e}{R^2} \approx 10^{13}\text{ V/m} \\ \theta_{\max} &\approx \frac{\Delta p}{p} \ll 1^\circ \end{aligned}$$
  • Weak Electric Field: Because positive charge was distributed over the entire atomic volume, the electrostatic field was far too dilute to cause substantial deflection.
  • Theoretical Failure: The model predicted that energetic $5.5\text{ MeV}$ $\alpha$-particles would pass straight through thin foils with cumulative deflections of at most a fraction of a degree. It was completely unable to explain large-angle scattering!
🔬

2. The Geiger-Marsden Landmark Experiment (1911)

Under Ernest Rutherford's direction, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden directed a collimated beam of $5.5\text{ MeV}$ $\alpha$-particles ($^{214}\text{Bi}$) at an ultra-thin gold foil ($t \approx 2.1 \times 10^{-7}\text{ m} \approx 800\text{ atoms}$ thick):

$$\begin{aligned} \text{Most Particles: } \theta &< 1^\circ \implies \text{Atom is mostly empty space} \\ \text{Deflection } \theta &> 90^\circ \approx 1\text{ in }8,000\text{ particles} \end{aligned}$$
  • Rutherford's Famous Remark: "It was quite the most incredible event that has ever happened to me in my life. It was almost as incredible as if you fired a 15-inch shell at a piece of tissue paper and it came back and hit you."
  • Nuclear Conclusion: All positive charge and practically all atomic mass must be concentrated in an unimaginably tiny core—the nucleus.
📐

3. Hyperbolic Coulomb Orbits & Impact Parameter $b$

The repulsive inverse-square Coulomb force between an $\alpha$-particle ($+2e$) and nucleus ($+Ze$) produces an exact Keplerian hyperbolic trajectory:

$$\begin{aligned} F(r) &= \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{2 Z e^2}{r^2} \\ b &= \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{Z e^2 \cot(\theta/2)}{K} \end{aligned}$$
  • Impact Parameter $b$: The perpendicular distance from the initial velocity vector to the target nucleus.
  • Head-on Collision ($b = 0$): $\cot(\theta/2) = 0 \implies \theta = 180^\circ$ (the particle decelerates to rest and rebounds along its incident line).
  • Large $b$ ($b \gg 10^{-14}\text{ m}$): Deflection angle $\theta \to 0^\circ$ (passes virtually undisturbed).
🎯

4. Distance of Closest Approach ($r_0$) & Nuclear Size

For a head-on impact ($b = 0$), all initial kinetic energy $K$ converts momentarily to electrostatic potential energy at the turning point $r_0$:

$$\begin{aligned} K &= \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{2 Z e^2}{r_0} \\ r_0 &= \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\frac{2 Z e^2}{K} = \frac{(8.99 \times 10^9) \times 2(79)(1.602 \times 10^{-19})^2}{5.5 \times 10^6 \times 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J}} \approx \mathbf{41.4\text{ fm}} \end{aligned}$$
  • Upper Bound on Nuclear Radius: Since the alpha particle turned around without experiencing nuclear strong forces, the gold nucleus must have radius $R < 41.4\text{ fm} = 4.14 \times 10^{-14}\text{ m}$.
  • Comparison: The nucleus is $10,000$ times smaller than the atom ($R_{\text{atom}} \sim 10^{-10}\text{ m}$)—analogous to a marble in the center of a football stadium!
📊

5. Rutherford's Differential Scattering Formula

By integrating all impact parameters in an annular ring $2\pi b\,db$, Rutherford derived the angular distribution of scattered particles per unit solid angle:

$$N(\theta) = \frac{N_i n t Z^2 e^4}{(8\pi\varepsilon_0)^2 r^2 K^2} \cdot \frac{1}{\sin^4(\theta/2)} \propto \frac{Z^2}{\sin^4(\theta/2)}$$
  • Inverse 4th-Power Dependence: $N(\theta)$ drops precipitously with angle. The count at $\theta = 10^\circ$ is over $4,000$ times greater than at $\theta = 90^\circ$!
  • Target Charge Law ($Z^2$): The scattering rate scales strictly with the square of the nuclear charge ($N \propto Z^2$).
  • Energy Dependence ($1/K^2$): Higher energy particles penetrate closer to the nucleus, reducing overall scattering angles ($N \propto 1/K^2$).
⚡

6. Classical Electrodynamic Instability (Prelude to Bohr)

While Rutherford's planetary model explained scattering, it faced a catastrophic theoretical paradox under classical Maxwellian electrodynamics:

$$\begin{aligned} P_{\text{Larmor}} &= \frac{e^2 a^2}{6\pi\varepsilon_0 c^3} > 0 \\ t_{\text{collapse}} &\approx \frac{(4\pi\varepsilon_0)^2 m_e^2 c^3 a_0^3}{4 e^4} \approx 10^{-11}\text{ seconds} \end{aligned}$$
  • Continuous Radiative Loss: An orbiting electron is constantly accelerating centripetally ($a = v^2/r$). By Larmor's theorem, it must continuously radiate electromagnetic waves, lose mechanical energy, and spiral into the nucleus within $10^{-11}\text{ s}$!
  • Continuous Spectrum Contradiction: As the orbital frequency increases continuously during the spiral, atoms should emit a continuous spectrum, contradicting the sharp discrete spectral lines observed in hydrogen. This dilemma motivated Niels Bohr's quantum postulate (1913).

About this series

Physics is best learned through exploration, experimentation, and visualization.

Developed by Dr. Ajith S Kumar, Department of Physics, D B Pampa College, Parumala, this collection brings Plus Two (Class 11 & 12) physics to life through interactive simulations. Each simulation is carefully designed around the concepts students find most challenging, helping learners develop a deeper understanding rather than simply memorize formulas. Aligned with the Kerala Higher Secondary (SCERT) and NCERT syllabus, it is open to every student, teacher, and physics enthusiast.